Intensive agriculture has led to widespread losses of native grasslands. Restoration projects are trying to reestablish native communities. However, the poor quality and altered food webs of former agricultural soils act as barriers to establishing diverse plant communities. Soil amendments such as biochar have been used to improve soil quality and increase crop yield, but little research has been on biochar in restoration settings. Eastern Washington University is attempting to restore a former wheat field to native Palouse prairie vegetation. In this study, we compared (1) soil abiotic properties and food webs between Palouse prairie remnants and Eastern Washington University’s (EWU) restoration site and (2) tested whether biochar can move soil conditions at EWU’s restoration site closer to those of remnant sites. We compared soils from three Palouse prairie remnants and EWU’s restoration site, and compared soils at the restoration site that were treated with different levels of biochar. Soil nematodes were extracted and sorted to functional groups as an assay of the structure and functional diversity of the soil food web. The soil at EWU’s restoration site had significantly lower nematode abundance, pH, and organic matter compared to prairie remnants. In addition, nematode abundance and pH increased significantly at the EWU site with the addition of biochar, both increasing to conditions similar to what is found at the prairie remnant sites. These results suggest biochar can improve some soil conditions in former agricultural lands even prior to native plant restoration.